Saturday, 23 September 2017

Leading the Use of Research and Evidence in Schools : Closing the rhetoric/reality gap

Recent research suggests there is a significant gap between the supportive rhetoric that some headteachers use about the use of research and evidence in their schools and the reality of practice on the ground (Caldwell, et al 2017).  So if you want to avoid getting caught in the gap between the rhetoric and reality, it will be worthwhile having some form of action-plan to help make sure you are creating the conditions for a culture of research and evidence use.  To do this, a useful place to start is the work of (Brown, 2015) who identified a check-list of actions for school leaders to take in developing a research and evidence informed school, and his illustrated in Figure 1.

Figure 1 Leading Research and Evidence Use in Schools - Themes, factors and sub-actions (adapted from Brown, 2015)

Theme
Factor
Sub-action
Transformational
Does your approach to research and evidence demonstrate your own commitment as well facilitate the efforts of others?
Promote a vision of research and evidence-informed school
Make resources available
Design and implement support structures
Create time and space for such work
·Make it part of everyone’s work (especially leaders)
Model the use of research and evidence in decision-making
Develop an enquiry habit of mind – look for new perspectives
Seek out new information
Explore new ways to tackle old problems

Does your approach to research and evidence use have buy-in throughout the school?
Adopt a distributive approach to leadership
Attend to the informal aspects of the school organisation
Identify and influence key-opinion formers and shapers
Seek to be consensual

Teaching and learning
Does your approach to research and evidence use ‘start with the end in mind’ and ensure that progress towards this end is tracked?
Articulate what success would look like
Consider what will need to be done differently
Question how things will be different for pupils and teachers
How will you know things are different?
Evaluate the impact of any changes
Engage in learning conversations – develop theories of action and develop and trial new actions 
Constantly refine processes and actions
Stop doing some things

Does your approach to research and evidence have teacher learning and practice at its core?
Continue to emphasise the importance of teacher-expertise
Use data to help teachers refine their practice 
Create opportunities for collaborative learning both inside and outside of the school
Continually focus on evidence
Draw in external experience and knowledge/theory
Develop protocols and ways of working
Create facilitative arrangements

Does your approach to research and evidence ensure that the right people are in the room
Develop middle leaders who are interested in evidence-informed practice 
Identify research and evidence champions
Involve people with the right mix of skills to support the use of research and evidence

As useful as this check-list is; from your perspective as an evidence-based school leader it is important to acknowledge its’ limitations. First, as regular readers of this blog will be aware evidence-based school leadership is not limited to issues related to pedagogy and teaching and learning but extends to all aspects of the school.  Second, the check-list does not make specific reference to ethical issues associated with evidence-based practice.  Third, the actions that you will wish to take will depend very much on the current context of your school and its' readiness to engager in research and evidence. Nevertheless, Brown’s work provides a very handy starting point for what you need to do as a school leader to initiate, implement and sustain an evidence-based school culture.

Next week 

We will look at a PARIiHS tool, which was developed in the health-care sector to help you judge the readiness of your school to engage with research.

BROWN, C. (Ed.) (2015). Leading the use of research & evidence in schools. London: IOE Press.

COLDWELL, M., GREANY, T., HIGGINS, S., BROWN, C., MAXWELL, B., B, S., STOLL, L., WILLIS, B. & BURNS, H. 2017. Evidence-informed teaching: an evaluation of progress in England Research report. London: Department for Education.



Friday, 8 September 2017

Leading evidence-informed teaching : the rhetoric and the reality

A recent report sponsored by the Department for Education suggests that there is a significant difference between the rhetoric and reality of evidence-informed teaching within schools, with a number of schools appearing to adopt the rhetoric of evidence-informed teaching, whilst at the same time not embedding research and evidence into their day to day practice (Coldwell et al., 2017).   Of the twenty-three schools involved in the report only six schools could be described as having a whole-school approach to research and evidence, with another seven schools where the head and senior leadership were proactive in their approach to a culture supporting the use of research and evidence, and finally, ten schools having an unengaged research evidence culture.  This finding was particularly surprising given the attention to creating a balanced sample of schools in how they are engaged with research evidence.

The difference between unengaged and highly engaged research evidence cultures is illustrated in the following table from Coldwell, et al 2017

 

So before I begin a series of posts where I can examine what can be done to close rhetoric reality gap – perhaps it would be worth undertaking a brief self-audit of which column best fits your school’s use of research evidence.   In doing so what I would like you to do if you locate yourself within the school leadership evidence culture and whole school evidence –culture is try and think of three pieces of supporting evidence – which you can use to support your judgement

Next week we will look at the what school leaders can actively do to make sure a rhetoric reality gap does not emerge. 

Reference

COLDWELL, M., GREANY, T., HIGGINS, S., BROWN, C., MAXWELL, B., B, S., STOLL, L., WILLIS, B. & BURNS, H. 2017. Evidence-informed teaching: an evaluation of progress in England Research report. London: Department for Education.